WATCH: Nada-Jane father leaves court frustrated as Hughes murder trial stalls
Hughes appears in black as proceedings are halted; the father of a four-year-old leaves frustrated after witnesses could not be called.
The sentencing proceedings against Amber Lee Hughes, charged with the premeditated murder and rape of four-year-old Nada-Jane Challita, were halted in the Johannesburg High Court today.
Hughes appeared in court dressed in black as the State was expected to begin calling witnesses.
@southern.courierHughes appears in black as proceedings are halted; father of four-year-old leaves frustrated after witnesses could not be called. Full story on southerncourier.co.za♬ original sound – Southern Courier
The case relates to the tragic killing of Nada-Jane at her Mulbarton home in January 2023. This marks yet another delay in the sentencing phase of the high-profile case.
Court unable to proceed
Despite expectations that witnesses would be called today, logistical issues prevented the matter from moving forward.
@southern.courierCourt unable to proceed Despite expectations that witnesses would be called today, logistical issues prevented the matter from moving forward. Full story on Southerncouroer.co.za♬ original sound – Southern Courier
State advocate Rolene Barnard told the court: “I understand that due to logistical issues, the court is not able to tend to this matter today.”
Judge Richard Mkhabela confirmed that a new date had been agreed upon by both parties, with the matter now set for April 15.
Father expected to testify
It was expected that Elie Chalita, the father of the deceased, would be the first witness called by the State.
Following the postponement, Chalita expressed frustration with the ongoing delays, saying the process was “a waste of time” before leaving the courtroom.
Context from previous proceedings
In earlier court appearances, Hughes confessed to the murder. She gave detailed testimony about the events surrounding Nada-Jane’s death, including how she drowned the child, and apologised to the family in court.
WATCH: Amber Lee Hughes recounts killing of four-year-old in shocking court testimony
During cross-examination, Hughes faced tough questioning from the State about contradictions in her story, messages she had sent, and her mental state at the time.
WATCH: Hughes apologises for drowning Nada, says she accepts she must be sentenced
She also discussed the impact of the child’s birthday on her statements and her claims regarding child welfare issues.
WATCH: Birthday cross-examination: Hughes grilled over messages and child welfare claims
These earlier proceedings provided insight into Hughes’ account and the State’s evidence, setting the stage for the sentencing phase of the trial.
WATCH: Hughes admits to lying under oath, blames previous legal counsel for missteps



