IO was ‘very serious’, court hears in breastfeeding mom’s murder
In 2024, the accused allegedly shot and killed a Pinetown mother while she was breastfeeding, and later the child's father.
DOUBLE murder accused Phiwinhlanhla Nzama (47) told the Durban High Court that he had refrained from informing the investigating officer (IO) about what he said is a common practice in his rural area of Kranskop, the random discharging of a firearm as a way of “showing off”, because on the day he was escorted to his homestead for the recovery of the weapon, the police officer “was very serious”.
Nzama was responding to cross-examination led by the State Prosecutor, Advocate Rakesh Singh, following his testimony in the trial in which he is accused of murdering a woman while she was breastfeeding, and her boyfriend, the child’s father, in the early hours of April 14, 2024, in the Nazareth area in Pinetown.
In response, Singh said Nzama should have told the IO, Detective Sergeant Noelin Chetty, about this practice, which the accused had told the court he had done two days prior from the date of his police escort, when he briefly visited his rural homestead.
Singh said this was important because when the gun was found by the police it had no ammunition, to which Nzama said this had been spent and depleted when he had randomly fired the weapon during his impromptu visit to his rural homestead.
The court heard that the firearm, to which Nzama has pleaded guilty for failing to lock away in a prescribed safe, was found buried at his Kranskop homestead. The accused testified he had hid it in such a manner since December 2023 because his licence for it had not been furnished to him following his application for a new one after losing the original in a robbery.
Nzama told the court that at the time, no one else had access to his firearm, and responding to Singh’s question as to what would his comment be if it is found that it had been used in the murders, he said he really would not know who had used it “because I am the only one who uses it”.
Nzama, who pleaded not guilty to the murders, added that his gun was not at any time stolen, because had it been, he would have reported it so to the nearest police station.
The court heard testimony from police officers who were first at the scene of the murders that they had found a bullet head next to the body of the child’s father which was later confirmed through ballistics testing that it matched Nzama’s licenced firearm.
“I heard that, there’s nothing I can comment about it because I did not fire any shot with my firearm there [at the scene of the murders, which is rental cottages in Nazareth, Pinetown,” Nzama told the court.
Also read: Child found suckling on mother after Pinetown murder, court hears
Nzama denied the truthfulness of some of the testimonies given by State witnesses; and he agreed under oath some of them were his friends.
These include that a couple of hours before the murders, on April 13, 2024, he spent parts of that day’s afternoon sharing drinks with a group of people, that included the deceased mother and her friend; that later on the evening of that day he had spent a considerable amount of time behind closed doors in his rented quarters with the deceased woman; that the late mother had asked him for drinking money; and that after having left the drinking spot, he later returned to the establishment to complain that the murdered woman and her friend had stolen R300 from his rented room.
“I really do not know why,” Nzama responded to Singh’s question about why witnesses would fabricate such evidence against him.
The matter, in which Nzama has conceded to some contradictions in his statement made to the police before the trial, and his testimony in court, was due to continue on Monday, November 16.
These contradictions include that in his statement he had told the police that he had been in possession of the firearm during his visit to Kranskop, while in court he testified that the gun had been left at the rural homestead.
Another contradiction is that in his statement, Nzama had said that when he arrived at his place of work on April 14, 2024, he found the individual he had travelled with to Kranskop, who had asked that he accompany him there, waiting for him, while in court he testified that the travel arrangements had been made telephonically.
“That is not true,” Nzama responded to Singh’s proposition that on the day of the murders, April 14, 2024, the accused had taken the firearm from his rented room to his place of work to place it in his locker and that after the police had fetched him from his place of work to search his living quarters, he realised he had to get rid of the weapon and so later that evening went back to work to fetch it and then proceeded to Kranskop.
The court heard testimony that on April 14, 2024, Nzama had clocked out of work late at night, which the accused explained as possibly occurring because he had had to fetch money from his locker that evening before leaving for Kranskop.
For more from the Highway Mail, follow us on Facebook , X and Instagram. You can also check out our videos on our YouTube channel or follow us on TikTok.
Click to subscribe to our newsletter here



