The High Court in Pretoria has granted interim relief on 31 July, ordering Tshwane’s city manager, Johann Mettler, to return to work after finding the process that led to his suspension was prima facie unlawful.

The judgement, delivered by Judge AJ Pillay on 31 July, relates to Mettler’s suspension following two council resolutions adopted on 9 July 2026.

The DA and Solidarity challenged the suspension, arguing that the Speaker unlawfully deducted 13 votes from the total votes cast.

They said this changed the outcome of the council decision and ultimately resulted in Mettler being suspended.

The Speaker argued that he had the discretion to exclude the votes of councillors who had been granted leave of absence, even though they attended the meeting and voted.

The court rejected this argument, finding that the Speaker did not have authority to subtract those votes. It held that councillors who were present, whether physically or virtually, were constitutionally entitled to vote.

Judge AJ Pillay therefore found the Speaker’s conduct to be prima facie unlawful.

The court ordered that Mettler’s suspension be set aside, allowing him to resume his duties as city manager. The respondents were also interdicted from implementing the suspension or appointing an acting city manager.

The court ruled the matter was urgent because of the risk of unlawful decisions being taken by an acting city manager while the legality of Mettler’s suspension remained in dispute.

The issues of costs and final relief were postponed for later determination.

Mettler told Rekord that sitting at home had been the most difficult experience because he believed he belonged at work.

“These past three weeks was an experience that no competent and willing and able city manager must go through, especially when you know that there is no reason for you to be at home, except for the fact that the majority of the council has made a wrong decision. So I am thankful and grateful for this judgement. I am so thankful that the good Lord has walked this path with me,” he said.

He added that many people across the country, including colleagues, friends and family, had contacted him to offer support.

“I look forward to going back. I want to take this council to the end of its term.”

Mettler said he wanted to continue the work he had started.

“Tshwane is a reasonably well-run metro. We have achieved significant milestones during this past period, and that is across the board. That must be concluded. I will do my best for this city, for its residents, for my colleagues and the staff of the city. We owe our best to the city.”

DA mayoral candidate Cilliers Brink welcomed the judgement, describing it as a victory beyond his party.

“Today’s judgement is a victory not only for the DA, but also for the rule of law, good governance and the residents of Tshwane,” Brink said.

He said the court had restored lawful administration in the city by ordering Mettler’s return to work as city manager.

Brink believes that by setting aside what he described as the unlawful decisions of the ANC-EFF-ActionSA coalition to suspend Mettler, the court had reaffirmed that political majorities cannot ignore the law, manipulate council processes or use municipal institutions to protect politically connected individuals.

He criticised the coalition’s handling of disciplinary matters, saying its decision to suspend Mettler, while giving what he described as “only a slap on the wrist” to an official implicated at the Madlanga Commission, the metro’s reinstated chief financial officer, Gareth Mnisi, exposed its priorities.

“The Court’s decision has confirmed that there are consequences when the law is ignored,” Brink said.

Brink also said the DA’s legal challenge relating to Mnisi would still proceed.

He said the party’s application to have what he described as Mnisi’s “ANC/EFF-engineered soft landing” declared invalid would still be heard by the court.

“We cannot interdict what has already happened, but we hope that we can overturn it in due course. In any event, we cannot un-see what we have seen at the Madlanga Commission and in forensic reports,” Brink said.

Freedom Front Plus councillor Grandi Theunissen said the judgement was expected because, in his view, the Speaker’s conduct had been unlawful and irrational.

Theunissen said the Freedom Front Plus would write to the MEC for Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs, Jacob Mamabolo, requesting the Speaker’s removal.

He also said those involved in what he described as the “fiasco” should be held personally accountable for the legal costs arising from the case. Five advocates represented the metro throughout the length of the proceedings.

Theunissen further criticised what he described as delaying tactics by the ANC in council, saying it was time for those tactics to be challenged and for justice to prevail, as it had in Mettler’s case.

He said Mettler had become a target of the coalition government because of his commitment to rooting out corruption, adding that it was unlawful to suspend him for that reason.

Solidarity chief executive Dirk Hermann welcomed the judgment, saying it was a victory for Johann Mettler, whom he described as the victim of a political power struggle.

Hermann said rules had been misused to achieve a political objective at the expense of an individual. He said Solidarity’s interest in the case was not political, but focused on protecting individual rights.

A legal source explained that the High Court’s order is an interim interdict rather than a final interdict.

The source said the interim order remains in place pending the outcome of the Democratic Alliance’s main application challenging Mettler’s suspension.

According to the source the distinction was largely academic in this case because Mettler’s three-month suspension would likely have expired by the time the main application is heard.

The source also said that, because the order is interim and not final, it would be difficult for the metro to appeal the ruling.

The office of the Mayor and the Deputy Mayor were contacted for comment, but no response was received at the time of publication.

Do you have more information about the story?

Please send us an email to bennittb@rekord.co.za or phone us on 083 625 4114.

For free breaking and community news, visit Rekord’s websites: Rekord East

For more news and interesting articles, like Rekord on Facebook, follow us on Twitter or Instagram or TikTok or WhatsApp Channel