Perimeter wall collapses again at Menlo Park garden refuse site
Overflowing waste, missing original building plans and past machinery collisions are all in the spotlight as the City of Tshwane investigates the latest structural failure.
The latest collapse of a perimeter wall at the Menlo Park garden refuse site has renewed concerns about the facility’s maintenance, with the City of Tshwane confirming that similar incidents have occurred in the past.
Ward 82 councillor Siobhan Muller said one side of the walls had completely collapsed, raising questions about its construction and whether it could withstand the pressure from accumulated garden refuse.
She raised concerns about the absence of drainage openings and the additional weight of waste piled up at the facility.
Muller also questioned whether the wall complied with appropriate construction standards, arguing that a single-brick wall should not exceed 1.8m in height and that the structure should have been double-brick, with engineering oversight and drainage openings.
“This is negligence and fruitless and wasteful expenditure,” she said.
City confirms previous incidents
Metro spokesperson Lindela Mashigo confirmed that the latest collapse was reported to the city on November 15, with a follow-up site investigation conducted on November 16.
“Preliminary reports indicate that heavy rainfall may have contributed to the collapse of the wall,” he said.
Mashigo said the underlying cause would need to be established through a technical assessment and that the city would consider whether a structural engineering assessment was necessary.
He confirmed that about three previous incidents involved sections of the wall collapsing after being accidentally struck by heavy machinery operating at the facility.
“In another incident, initially suspected to be a structural failure, investigations established that a service provider had struck the wall,” said Mashigo.
He added that an insurance claim was abandoned, and the service provider was held responsible for the repairs.
“Previous repairs following machinery-related damage were funded by the respective machinery owners,” Mashigo said.
However, Mashigo did not confirm the original approved height or construction specifications because the original site plans and associated construction documents are unavailable in the city’s records.
An archival search will be initiated to locate them.


Site operations and insurance process
The latest collapse follows complaints in April about overflowing garden refuse, unpleasant smells and flies at the facility, when the city said additional trucks had been deployed and wall repairs were under way.
Mashigo said waste collection trucks are now removing accumulated garden refuse daily and transporting it to the designated landfill site.
“The city is also assessing the structural integrity of the remaining walls to establish whether further safety interventions are needed,” said Mashigo.
Mashigo said refuse close to the damaged section was being removed to create working space so the area could be cordoned off and barricaded against unauthorised access. The site remains open.
The incident will be reported for consideration under the city’s insurance provisions.
However, no repair completion date is available, as work will proceed once the necessary insurance processes have been concluded.
Mashigo said the city remained responsible for maintaining the facility and would consider accountability measures if investigations established negligence or non-compliance.
Also read: Level 2 water restrictions imposed as consumption exceeds allocation
Do you have more information about the story?
Please send us an email to bennittb@rekord.co.za or phone us on 083 625 4114.
For free breaking and community news, visit Rekord’s websites: Rekord East
For more news and interesting articles, like Rekord on Facebook, follow us on Twitter or Instagram or TikTok or WhatsApp Channel