Knives in schoolbags, threats and murder: What is happening to South Africa’s children?

From schoolyard confrontations that end in murder to teenagers accused of attacking much younger children, incidents reported over the past year raise difficult questions about why some South African children are turning to extreme violence.

A school should be a place where children learn, make friends and prepare for their futures. Yet, for some South African families, sending a child to school has become an exercise in worry.

Will their child come home safely? Will an argument between learners end in a fight? And what happens when a teenager pulls out a knife instead of walking away?

Over the past year, Caxton’s local newsrooms have reported a disturbing number of incidents involving children and teenagers accused of serious violence, including stabbing fellow learners, attacking teachers and, in some cases, killing others.

In February, Soweto Urban reported on a Grade 9 learner who allegedly stabbed a Grade 11 pupil three times at Curro Protea Glen. The incident reportedly followed an earlier confrontation in which the victim had tried to intervene in an altercation between other learners.

His mother said her son had been threatened before the attack. He was admitted to intensive care and later recovered.

A month later, the Carletonville Herald reported on violence between learners at Badirile Secondary School in Khutsong, Carletonville. A Grade 9 learner died after allegedly being stabbed by a 17-year-old Grade 10 learner following an altercation on the school grounds.

The Gauteng Department of Education dispatched psychosocial support services to the school, while police investigated the incident.

In June, Ridge Times reported that a learner at Ikusasalethu Comprehensive School in eMbalenhle, Secunda, was allegedly stabbed 15 times by a fellow pupil during the lunch break. The victim was rushed to hospital with serious injuries and the suspected attacker was charged with attempted murder.

Incidents are not confined to confrontations between teenage learners.

In October, a six-year-old girl was critically injured after allegedly being stabbed several times at a school in KZN. A 16-year-old boy was arrested, reported the North Coast Courier.

The publication subsequently investigated the teenager’s alleged history of threats, disturbing online activity and previous incidents involving weapons.

In Limpopo, parents at Sinthumule Secondary School in Ramahantsha near Louis Trichardt demanded action after two learners were stabbed in separate incidents on October 21 and 22.

According to the Polokwane Review, parents raised concerns about bullying, gangsterism, substance abuse and alleged drug dealing among learners.

In a non-school-related incident involving a child suspect, a 14-year-old was arrested this month after a 51-year-old domestic worker was fatally shot on a farm outside Barberton. The teenager allegedly used a shotgun belonging to his uncle, reported the Lowvelder.

A country with a long history of violence

The recent cases are disturbing, but they are part of a much longer story. To understand why violence can become normalised among some young people, it is necessary to look beyond the school gates and at the social conditions that have shaped South African communities for generations.

Apartheid left a legacy of structural inequality, poverty, overcrowding and social exclusion, while violence became entrenched in many communities.

Historian Clive Glaser’s research into youth gangs in Soweto between 1968 and 1976 documented how gangs became an alternative social structure for unemployed or unschooled young men.

His research examined the relationship between youth gangs, schools, territorial identity and the social conditions of the time.

Although the circumstances have changed since 1994, inequality, unemployment, social exclusion and gangsterism remain realities in many communities.

A systematic review published in Child Indicators Research in 2022 examined 34 studies on the perceptions and experiences of violence among South African children, adolescents and young people.

The researchers identified three major themes: Exposure to violence, gender-based and sexual violence, and interpersonal and school violence.

The review identified low socioeconomic conditions, the consequences of apartheid, traditional expectations of masculinity and male entitlement as contributing factors in the broader patterns of youth violence.

When violence becomes part of everyday life

One of the most concerning findings in South African research is how frequently children are exposed to violence in their everyday environments.

A 2018 study published in the South African Medical Journal in 2018 followed children growing up in Johannesburg and Soweto and looked at their exposure to violence. The findings showed that only 1% of the study participants had not been exposed to or experienced violence at home, school or in their communities.

Two-thirds of school-going children had been exposed to community violence, while more than half had experienced violence at home.

About 40% had experienced or been exposed to five or six different categories of violence during their lives.

What makes a child capable of extreme violence?

Prof Christiaan Bezuidenhout, a criminologist at the University of Pretoria whose research focuses on psychocriminology and juvenile misbehaviour, has examined the circumstances that influence children to commit serious offences.

His study, co-authored by Melanie Moen, explored the relationship between childhood adversity and extreme violence. Many of the children in the cases examined had experienced more than one form of adversity, including poverty, neglect and abuse.

The researchers used the General Aggression Model to explore how repeated adverse experiences may influence the development of aggressive behaviour.

The study highlighted the importance of stable and supportive environments in children’s lives.

Can the cycle be broken?

South African research suggests that preventing violence among children requires more than disciplinary action after an incident has occurred.

Parents, educators, social workers, police, psychologists and community organisations all have a role in identifying warning signs and providing support before conflict escalates.

Bullying, repeated threats, access to weapons, gang involvement, substance abuse and exposure to violence are all issues that deserve attention.

Schools also need effective reporting systems and access to professional support when learners display concerning behaviour.

At the same time, protecting children who are victims of violence must remain a priority. Understanding the circumstances of a young offender should never mean excusing the harm inflicted on another child or family.

Breaking news at your fingertips… Follow Caxton Network News on Facebook and join our WhatsApp channel.

Nuus wat saakmaak. Volg Caxton Netwerk-nuus op Facebook en sluit aan by ons WhatsApp-kanaal.

At Caxton, every story is written by humans. We use AI only to perform quality checks - never to generate the news. Happy reading!

Support local journalism

Add The Citizen as a preferred source to see more from Network News in Google News and Top Stories.

Caxton reporter

This article is a compilation of reports by various Caxton publications about child killers in their respective areas, brought together by a Caxton Network News journalist.
Back to top button