Has prosecutor succeeded in proving murder-accused Pistorius’s intent to kill?

Whether State Prosecutor Gerrie Nel has succeeded in proving murder-accused Oscar Pistorius's intent to kill after the Paralympian finished his testimony this week is not yet clear.

Wits School of Law Professor James Grant said Nel had, however, succeeded in showing Pistorius was considering the implications of his testimony. “The accuracy of the detail was highlighted by Nel, who asked the same question from various angles to reveal inconsistencies. This was clear, with Pistorius not being able to explain certain things in his testimony,” said Grant. “A few contradictions were evident.”

Nel’s cross-examination of Pistorius ended on Tuesday after five brutal days that saw the Paralympian continuously break- ing down and crying.

Nel said he had no further questions after presenting the prosecution’s case that Pistorius was lying in his account.

Professor Karthy Govender, a professor of law at the University of KwaZulu-Natal, said any judge would look at whether the accused’s explanation of what transpired at the time of the murder was reasonably true or not. “His examination included testing if Pistorius’s version was improbable,” said Govender. “What is next is calling witnesses to the stand to try and prove that there is any reasonable doubt.”

On Tuesday Pistorius claimed he heard the magazine rack moving in the bathroom before he fired the shots.

Nel countered by showing the court a photo of the cubicle with one leg of the rack in a pool of blood – with no smear marks on the floor.

Wits Centre for Ethics director Professor Lucy Allais said Nel’s cross-examination should be judged by the standards of a court of law.

“Nel’s job is to prosecute Pistorius for the extremely serious charge of murder. Harsh probing does not, therefore, seem to me to be inappropriate,” she said.

Read more on these topics

Gerrie Nel Oscar Trial Reeva Steenkamp

Access premium news and stories

Access to the top content, vouchers and other member only benefits