Crime that funds classrooms

A landmark court ruling forces a cigarette seller to fund desks for local schools, benefiting pupils and justice alike.


The sellers of illegal cigarettes are, according to the SA Revenue Service, posing a significant threat to the fiscus because of their avoidance of duties and value added tax.

That’s why a conviction of such a seller – and accompanying hefty fine – is something to be welcomed.

But, the Evander Regional Court went a step further this week in imposing a further punishment which will have a direct social benefit.

Uptown Superstore was fined R600 000 – but must also buy 504 durable, quality double-seater desks for four schools in the area.

ALSO READ: Company found guilty of illicit cigarette trade, fined R600k and ordered to buy desks for schools

The company has three months to comply with the court judgment.

Major-General Nico Gerber, provincial head of the Directorate for Priority Crime Investigation, was a master of understatement in calling it “an interesting sentence…” But was spot-on when he added: “The community is benefiting from this sentence and it will definitely assist the next generation in their needs for a better education.”

We suggest that other courts take judicial notice of that sentence and consider imposing similar punishments.

A crime which affects the community – and smuggling does that by taking tax revenue away from where it could be spent improving lives – should have some sort of payback which helps the community.

NOW READ: Vodacom scores ConCourt win over Please Call Me inventor Nkosana Makate

Support Local Journalism

Add The Citizen as a Preferred Source on Google and follow us on Google News to see more of our trusted reporting in Google News and Top Stories.

Read more on these topics

Courts and Crime Editorials Illegal Cigarettes