Leadership’s most harmful practice is defensiveness: leaders do not avoid errors; instead, their defensive behaviour blocks the process of learning from their mistakes.

Leaders who express anger or denial, or make counteraccusations, or remain silent when faced with criticism, demonstrate that they value their public image above all else. Leadership shifts into self-defence mode in that instant.

Trust starts to fade away after someone experiences damage to their trust relationship.

South Africans recognise this pattern, which they have experienced before.

The organisation responds to concerns from citizens, employees, communities, and journalists with defensive behaviour rather than active listening.

The situation has been ignored, and no form of reflection has been offered during this process.

The system relies on deflection as its primary response rather than developing accountability systems.

People have learned through experience that expressing themselves can be either useless or dangerous, or lead to dangerous consequences.

People lose the ability to communicate honestly, which prevents institutions from using their built-in correction mechanisms.

READ MORE HERE: Coffee with Reverend Maans – character over charisma, why we keep choosing wrong leaders

Defensiveness thrives where leadership is confused with personal worth

People develop automatic responses to leadership rather than thoughtful ones because they see criticism as an attack on their personal identity rather than their professional conduct.

The organisation decided to protect its reputation, but this decision led to the loss of its current business relationships. Leadership is independent of a person’s values.

The duty requires professionals to maintain continuous learning, adapt their methods, and demonstrate humility in their work.

Leaders who cannot separate critique from personal insult are not strong; they are insecure, and insecurity is costly in positions of power.

Mature leadership understands that criticism is not always opposition.

Often, it is an attempt to protect what matters.

Employees raise concerns because they care about their workplace.

Citizens protest because they care about their future. Communities complain because something essential is not working.

READ MORE HERE: Coffee with Reverend Maans – the moral compass for a nation in need

When leaders treat every critique as hostility, they silence the very voices that could help them lead better

Trust research consistently shows that people are far more willing to forgive mistakes than they are to tolerate denial or defensiveness.

A leader who says, “I got this wrong,” and demonstrates change, regains credibility faster than one who insists on being right at all costs.

Yet defensiveness remains common because it offers short-term emotional relief.

It avoids embarrassment. It preserves control.

But it does so at the expense of long-term trust.

In workplaces, defensive leadership produces disengagement

People do the minimum required. Creativity disappears. Loyalty erodes. In public life, defensiveness deepens cynicism.

Citizens disengage or turn hostile. Institutions lose legitimacy. The damage is cumulative.

Each unaddressed breach of trust makes the next one harder to repair.

The alternative is not weak or permissive leadership. It is teachable leadership.

Leaders who maintain security in their listening abilities create conditions that allow trust to develop through their acceptance of difficult feedback.

They understand that listening does not mean agreement, and accountability does not mean humiliation.

They know that authority is strengthened, not diminished, when leaders take responsibility and model integrity.

Rebuilding trust after it has been damaged is not a quick process

It requires intentional, relational work. Leaders must first acknowledge that trust has been broken, without minimising the impact or explaining it away.

They must take responsibility for their role, apologise sincerely, and commit to visible change.

Trust is restored not through speeches, but through consistent behaviour over time. People watch closely.

They remember. And they decide whether it is safe to trust again.

READ MORE HERE: Coffee with Reverend Maans – Ubuntu teaches that leadership exists for the well-being of the community

This process requires vulnerability — not emotional exposure for its own sake, but the courage to be honest about failure

Vulnerability-based trust grows when leaders are willing to say, “I don’t know,” “I was wrong,” or “I need help.”

These words do not weaken leadership. They humanise it. They invite collaboration.

They signal that the organisation or community is more important than ego.

South Africa urgently needs leaders who can tolerate discomfort without becoming defensive.

Leaders who can receive criticism without rage.

Leaders who can hold tension without retreating into silence or aggression.

Such leadership does not emerge from charisma or control, but from character and stewardship.

It recognises that leadership exists to serve people, not to protect personal pride.

Defensiveness may preserve authority in the short term, but it destroys trust in the long term.

Teachable leadership, by contrast, may feel slower and riskier, but it builds something far more durable: confidence that leaders can be trusted to act responsibly even when they fail. In a country carrying deep wounds and high expectations, that confidence is not a luxury.

It is essential.

If South Africa is to rebuild trust, leaders must learn to see criticism not as an enemy, but as a gift — imperfect, sometimes painful, but often necessary.

Trust does not grow where leaders are always right. It grows where leaders are willing to be accountable.

Christian reflection

Scripture offers enduring wisdom for leadership under pressure: “Everyone should be quick to listen, slow to speak and slow to become angry” (James 1:19).

This counsel recognises that restraint, listening, and humility are not weaknesses, but sources of strength.

This column is the opinion of the writer and does not represent the views of Witbank News.

Your city, your story, as it happens. Stay in the loop with WITBANK NEWS.
Find us on our  website, Facebook, X,  Instagram or TikTok

Got a tip? Email: info@witbanknews.co.za