Right of reply: Proposed Bill will deliver devolution not Cape independence

"Where people don’t vote ANC, they don’t deserve to live in a failed state," said Zille


The Western Cape Peoples Bill is not about Cape independence but about delivering the devolution of powers which the Western Cape voted for in 2019, but which that government has been unable to deliver.

Premier Alan Winde was elected on a promise to fight for the devolution of policing powers and budgets from national to provincial government and a devolved provincial rail service which is safe and which runs on time.

He has officially requested both, but his appeals have been denied by national government. national government fails to fulfil its constitutional duties.

In the 2021 election campaign, DA federal chair Helen Zille said: “The DA has always supported federalism and will continue driving devolution of power and regional autonomy. Where people don’t vote ANC, they don’t deserve to live in a failed state.”

NOW READ: Cape ‘homeland’ a thinly veiled yearning for the past

‘Fundamental principle of international law’

Zille’s comments are not only morally incontrovertible, they articulate a fundamental principle of international law – that all people have an “undeniable and inalienable” right to self-determination.

Since 1994, South Africa has signed and ratified three different international treaties, all of which guarantee this right, and self-determination is a principle of the constitution.

A UN report recently clarified that self-determination could be exercised in one of four ways: devolution, federalism, independence, or unification.

The Western Cape Peoples Bill will claim the right of self-determination for the province so that the premier can not only claim devolved powers by right, but that the Western Cape can also claim full federal autonomy within the South African state.

Autonomy bill

A “Western Cape Federal Autonomy Bill” is currently being written and, in addition to devolving powers including policing and rail, it will include a provincial veto on constitutional changes which affect the province, and which would allow the provincial government to step in when the Given the frank admission by DA leader John Steenhuisen that an ANC/EFF doomsday coalition is a distinct possibility, taking measures to protect those areas where the DA already govern is essential.

It is also required by the Western Cape constitution. Significantly, this is a solution other provinces who reject the ANC and EFF in 2024 can also apply.

-Craig is the cofounder and spokesperson of the Cape Independence Advocacy Group and not the leader of the Cape Independence Party, as was previously stated in error in the article ‘Cape independence ‘won’t fly’’ on 14 April.

READ MORE: Cape independence is a ‘pipe dream’ not even the DA could support

Read more on these topics

Alan Winde Helen Zille Western Cape