Experts divided on call for Zim sanctions to be lifted
SA cannot prosper in a sea of misery, one expert said, while another maintained it would be tantamount to supporting Mugabe’s legacy of dictatorship.
In this file photo taken on September 2, 2019 Leon Kufakunesu gathers jackalberry fruit onto a plate which his mother has resorted to serving the family as a midday meal while saving up the little mealie meal left for dinner, at Buhera in Zimbabwe’s Manicaland Province. Picture: Jekesai NJIKIZANA / AFP
Speaker of the National Assembly Thandi Modise supported a motion at the 46th Plenary Assembly session of the Southern African Development Community parliamentary forum calling for an end to economic sanctions on Zimbabwe.
The motion was tabled by Angolan ambassador Josefina Perpetua Pitra Diakite, who highlighted the impact of sanctions.
Political economy expert Zamikhaya Maseti said it was time SA backed Zimbabwe against sanctions.
“[SA is] directly affected by the crisis in Zimbabwe. We have about five million Zimbabweans living and working in SA. If we don’t work to stabilise that economy and for the sanctions to be lifted, that is going to be more of an economic burden,” said Maseti.
ALSO READ: PICS: Aid agencies throw lifeline to hungry Zimbabweans
But for political analyst Andre Duvenhage, SA’s support of the lifting of sanctions was tantamount to supporting former ruler Robert Mugabe’s legacy of dictatorship.
He said it was a symptom of SA’s lack of a moral compass that the government was seen by the international community to be supporting the Zimbabwean government on the issue of sanctions.
“Even though [current President Emmerson] Mnangagwa has not done anything to change the economic situation in Zimbabwe, SA does not follow high moral values, so it is not surprising they support dictatorships with poor human rights records,” he said.
Maseti, however, argued that Mugabe’s legacy was not a rational reason to support the sanctions.
“We cannot punish the new regime … there is no justification for those sanctions to still hold. As they say, SA cannot prosper in a sea of misery.”
Faced with record-breaking inflation and a looming humanitarian crisis, Zimbabwe’s economy failed to bounce back after the historic general election in 2017, which ended Mugabe’s reign.
A year later, his successor has struggled to live up to the promise of economic growth.
According to the UN, about five million Zimbabweans are currently in need of food aid.
In March, this year, US President Donald Trump extended economic sanctions against Zimbabwe by a year, saying they would not be removed unless political reforms took place.
About 141 entities and top officials in Zimbabwe were on the US sanction list.
– simnikiweh@citizen.co.za
For more news your way, download The Citizen’s app for iOS and Android.
For more news your way
Download our app and read this and other great stories on the move. Available for Android and iOS.
