Shaw, now 20, was instantly linked with Tendulkar when he matched the feat of the ‘Little Master’ by scoring centuries for Mumbai on his debuts in the domestic Ranchi and Duleep tournaments in 2017.
He then led India to victory at the Under-19 World Cup, and burst into the Test team in 2018 with a match-winning 134 against West Indies, becoming the youngest Indian to score a century on debut at 18 years, 10 months and 25 days.
But since then, the boyish batsman has followed a rocky path.
An ankle injury ruled him out of India’s historic first Test series triumph in Australia last year, and he was then slapped with a back-dated eight-month ban for taking a prohibited anti-asthma drug.
“He is a special talent and I am a little disappointed with the way things have taken its course after his ankle injury and then his ban for using the banned substance,” former Test opener Wasim Jaffer told AFP.
“Seeing all this troubles me, because he is very, very talented. But he needs to be disciplined if he wants to achieve great things.
“He is living in that Indian circle where he has got role models like Virat Kohli, Rohit Sharma, Shikhar Dhawan who are so disciplined.”
– Schoolboy sensation –
Jaffer, who played 31 Tests for India, added: “There is much competition and he missed so many Tests and internationals and does not need to do that because this is his time to fulfil his potential.”
Shaw, who has played four Tests and three ODIs, made headlines around the world as a 14-year-old when he smashed a record 546 off 330 balls in a 2013 school competition.
That evoked memories of Tendulkar’s 326 not out in his 664-run partnership with Vinod Kambli in the same tournament, the Harris Shield, in 1988. Comparisons have been made ever since.
Shaw has admitted there is a downside to being constantly likened to Tendulkar, a hero among cricket fans who holds the record for runs in Tests and one-day internationals.
“There is pressure when people compare me to him. But I take it as a challenge. I try to play like him. He is the god of cricket,” Shaw told an online discussion with the Delhi Capitals, his Indian Premier League franchise.
Jaffer said Shaw has to be mentally equipped to deal with the pressures, like any international star.
“Whenever you perform at the top level, the media and the people hype you so much, but it is an individual’s responsibility to learn,” said Jaffer.
“Virat keeps himself grounded. Every rising batsman in Mumbai circles is right away compared to Tendulkar. Everything boils down to performance.”
Shaw, who was only eight when he first met Tendulkar, said he regards the batting legend as a mentor and sometimes speaks to him about the mental challenges of the game.
“Now also whenever I go for practice, if Sachin Sir is there to watch me, he will talk, not much technically but mentally more,” Shaw said, during a live chat on Instagram.
Veteran commentator Charu Sharma believes Shaw has lived up to the intense hype.
“Because when you play school cricket or local league cricket, the leap from there to international cricket is a Grand Canyon. He has taken that leap and has landed on the right side because of all the early work he did,” Sharma told AFP.
“Prithvi, like Rohit Sharma and Tendulkar, can adjust very well despite his aggressive stance and can assess the ball quicker than many other cricketers.
He added: “If he keeps himself physically well, mentally he is a very strong kid, he will be able to play for India for a very long time”.