Government must intervene with US tariffs, act stronger with police corruption

Government must urgently consider interventions to lower US tariffs as South Africa braces for the impact of them. In addition, people expected stronger action from President Cyril Ramaphosa to deal with the corruption in the police.

Busisiwe Mavuso, CEO of Business Leadership South Africa (BLSA), says in her weekly newsletter that the notification from the White House that many of South Africa’s exports will face 30% tariffs from August is “deeply concerning”.

“While there may be scope to negotiate some reprieve, we must prepare for the worst-case scenario. Although exports from SA to the US make up just 2.2% of gross domestic product (GDP), some of that basket will be unaffected because there are specific exemptions, particularly for raw materials, such as platinum, gold, chrome and coal that the US deems critical.

“The most critical sectors to be affected are vehicles and parts, agricultural output, steel and aluminium (which faces 50%) and other manufactured goods. That will hit certain companies hard where they are significantly exposed to the US market.”

ALSO READ: Ordinary South Africans will feel impact of US tariffs

Businesses affected will find other markets, but it takes time

She says some of those businesses will be able to find new markets for their output, but that takes time. In the short term, they will face a shock that will ripple through their supply chains. She said she worries about how the automotive sector will withstand this.

She points out it is not just vehicle manufacturers, but the many parts manufacturers and other service providers who support them. “Under the Trump tariff regime, vehicles and parts will get their own tariff of 25%.

“The US acquired R35 billion in luxury cars and components last year, with a third of that consisting of parts, many provided by relatively small businesses.

“The citrus industry is also bracing for a huge impact. South Africa has become the world’s second-largest citrus exporter after Spain, but the biggest in the southern hemisphere, positioning it well for northern hemisphere winter demand.”

ALSO READ: Trump’s new 30% tariff less about trade and more about power

The US market consumed around R1.8 billion of citrus exports, supporting about 140 000 jobs across the value chain. “Add to that wine, beef and other exports and large parts of our agricultural sector will be hit.

“The critical question is whether affected companies can survive long enough to pivot to new markets. Shifting production capabilities and securing alternative import agreements takes years, not months. In the interim, hundreds of thousands of jobs hang in the balance.”

Urgent decisions needed on US tariffs

Mavuso says government must make urgent policy decisions. “Much like during Covid, when companies were forced to close during lockdowns, the shocks are temporary. But losing companies and the thousands of jobs would be permanent.

“Then, government took the decision to support companies with loan schemes and support jobs with the Temporary Employer/Employee Relief Scheme (Ters). Similar interventions should urgently be considered to deal with the tariff fallout.”

Of course, she says, government should also actively engage their US counterparts to find ways to avoid the full impact of the tariffs, but we must prepare for the worst. We cannot be left scrambling for a solution only after all other options have failed, she says.

ALSO READ: Where Trump’s tariffs will hurt most

She points out that government’s recent R753 million emergency funding for HIV programmes, necessitated by the US withdrawal of Pepfar, demonstrates a model for the challenge and response. “While this represents only a tenth of Pepfar’s previous spending, it shows government can move quickly when crises demand action.

“We must get ahead of this challenge. Government should immediately establish a tariff impact fund to support viable companies through the transition period while simultaneously working with affected industries to identify and develop alternative markets. Parallel diplomatic efforts with US counterparts remain important, but we cannot wait for their outcome.”

Police corruption also needs urgent attention

Turning to the governance crisis exemplified by the Senzo Mchunu affair, Mavuso says the crisis also demands urgent attention.

“The decision Ramaphosa announced last night to grant the police minister leave of absence is welcome, although proper suspension pending investigation would have been more appropriate given the serious allegations of lying to parliament and interfering in police investigations of political assassinations in KwaZulu-Natal.

“The president’s appointment of Firoz Cachalia as acting minister does suggest an effort to put someone into the role without political baggage and is welcome. However, it would have been better to see stronger action.

“Just two weeks ago, the president dismissed a deputy minister for the relatively minor infraction of taking an overseas trip without final approval. If we fire officials for procedural violations, how can we treat potential obstruction of justice investigations with less severity?”

Inquiry’s recommendations must not gather dust again

The commission of inquiry offers hope, provided it receives proper resources to support Acting Deputy Chief Justice Mbuyisile Madlanga, who has been appointed to head it, she says.

“The Nugent Commission on Sars and the PIC Commission successfully contributed to restoring those institutions, proving commissions can work when properly structured and supported.

“However, we cannot afford the delays and budget overruns that have plagued other inquiries, nor can we allow recommendations to gather dust like many from the Zondo Commission on state capture. Judge Madlanga will need to be swift and recommend immediate actions to suspend those who pose particular risk to the security services.”

ALSO READ: Cameron questions urgency of commission into Mchunu probe

Mavuso says this situation strikes at the heart of our criminal justice system.

“Police must have unwavering political backing to investigate crime without fear or favour. Any suggestion of political interference is devastating to public trust and emboldens criminal syndicates that have infiltrated our political systems.

“These networks must be dismantled and the president must lead this charge by ensuring police have his full backing to pursue investigations wherever they lead.”