Black Friday: Are the bargains as good as retailers claim?

November brings weeks of promotions, but as November 27 approaches, shoppers face the challenge of separating genuine bargains from inflated discounts and increasingly sophisticated scams.

Once a much-anticipated day of savings, Black Friday was quickly joined by Cyber Monday, then evolved into Black November.

The jury is out on whether the retail frenzy stretches consumers’ rands as far as it has stretched the shopping season.

One thing is certain, however. While Black Friday does offer several genuine deals, it also provides fertile hunting grounds for scammers – both criminal operators and unethical retailers who advertise a ‘sale price’ against a marked-up original price.

When asked if consumers respond to genuine savings, or to the perception of getting a bargain, Nicola Allen, senior retail analyst at South African fast-moving consumer goods retail research company Trade Intelligence, said there are ‘strong perceptions of getting a bargain’.

Are the deals still worth it?

“South Africans headed into Black Friday 2025 with extraordinary optimism, but the reality of the day delivered a far more muted experience than many had hoped,” she said.

According to Trade Intelligence’s Black Friday surveys, only 11% of respondents said the 2025 deals truly impressed them, giving the event a satisfaction score of four or five. Meanwhile, nearly half (47%) rated the event poorly (scores of one or two), and 29% described it as average.

A decade ago, Black Friday was driven by steep discounts on sought-after products such as technology and appliances, with retailers sometimes selling at or below cost to get customers through the door. Today, with promotions spread across Black November, retailers cannot sustain such deep discounts for weeks.

“For retailers, defining the right ‘strategy’ is walking a fine line, trying to optimise volume while protecting margin as far as possible,” said Allen.

At the same time, consumers have become more cautious about how they spend. Marcel Jansen van Rensburg, credit card data science manager at FNB, said that in 2025, customers focused on necessities while still spending on less expensive treats and other non-essential items.

“Compared with previous years, there was a clear shift away from big-ticket discretionary categories such as travel,” he said.

“Groceries spend grew at a faster rate than in previous years. At the same time, FNB recorded increased spending on entertainment, digital and tech.”

2025 trends

FNB data for Black Friday 2025 shows that the top spending categories were ranked as follows:

  • Groceries
  • Clothing and non-perishables
  • Entertainment
  • Transportation
  • Home
  • Other
  • Travel
  • Digital and technology
  • Medical and funeral

Other notable findings from FNB include:

  • In-store virtual card payments grew by 29.5% year-on-year, compared with 2% for physical cards.
  • Online virtual card payments grew by 25% year-on-year, compared with 5% for physical cards.
  • Digital and tech was the fastest-growing spending category, up 14% year-on-year.

Allen said a major South African supermarket chain cited Black Friday as a key contributor to reduced profitability in its financial results for the 26 weeks ended March 27. The retailer described its Black Friday campaign as ineffective: “Although Black Friday delivered sales growth, it came at a significant cost to gross profit margins.”

Don’t be scammed

Black Friday scams may be more polished than in the past. However, many still rely on familiar tactics, according to Robert Swanepoel, technical expert for the Sub-Saharan region at Kaspersky, and Nick Harris, head of financial crime at Capitec.

“AI allows fraudsters to build convincing websites, generate realistic product images and fabricate client reviews within minutes,” said Harris.

Swanepoel also warned of new AI-related risks. If you use AI chatbots or shopping tools to search for deals, cybercriminals could trick them with a tactic called prompt injection to send you to fake or dangerous websites.

Shoppers should be wary of discounts that seem too good to be true, particularly 70% to 80% off popular products, as well as countdown timers, limited-stock claims and other tactics designed to create urgency.

Fake retailers may copy legitimate branding and product images, while subtle changes to a web address can be easy to miss. Poorly written text, missing contact details, unclear returns information and a lack of credible independent reviews are further warning signs.

Harris added that shoppers should be careful on social media, especially with new online stores that have little sales history, limited client engagement or comment sections that have been turned off.

Before buying, verify the retailer and promotion through its official website or app. Avoid clicking on links in unsolicited emails, SMSes or social media posts. Virtual cards can provide an added layer of protection for online purchases.

If something seems suspicious, or goods are not delivered as promised, contact your bank as soon as possible. Early reporting can help protect your account and prevent others from becoming victims.

Breaking news at your fingertips… Follow Caxton Network News on Facebook and join our WhatsApp channel.

Nuus wat saakmaak. Volg Caxton Netwerk-nuus op Facebook en sluit aan by ons WhatsApp-kanaal.

Read original story on www.citizen.co.za

At Caxton, every story is written by humans. We use AI only to perform quality checks - never to generate the news. Happy reading!

Support local journalism

Add The Citizen as a preferred source to see more from Network News in Google News and Top Stories.

Cathy Grosvenor

Skilled writer, sub-editor, proofreader and PR practitioner. Winner of multiple Caxton, Sanlam and MDDA community press awards. Served as judge for both the Sanlam and Caxton community press awards. Over 30 years of experience; 15 of which were spent as the editor of an award-winning community newspaper.
Back to top button