High Court ruling reopens public participation in JB Marks demerger process

Residents in Potchefstroom and Ventersdorp will have at least 21 days to submit written views as the demarcation board is ordered to pay the DA's legal costs.

The demerger of JB Marks Local Municipality into separate municipalities for Potchefstroom and Ventersdorp is back on the table after the High Court ruled that the Municipal Demarcation Board (MDB) must restart part of the process and reconsider its decision.

This follows the High Court setting aside the MDB’s decision to retain the existing municipal boundaries rather than reverse the merger of the former Tlokwe and Ventersdorp municipalities, reports the Potchefstroom Herald.

The judgment does not mean that Potchefstroom and Ventersdorp will immediately become separate municipalities again. The MDB must reconsider the matter, and the final decision on whether JB Marks should remain intact or its boundaries should change still rests with the board.

Read here: Ventersdorp residents battle service collapse as hung JB Marks council sparks hope

Acting Judge Stephen Vivian of the Gauteng Division of the High Court delivered the judgment on Friday (November 13), after a legal challenge by the Democratic Alliance (DA) against the MDB’s decision of July 30, 2025, to retain the existing JB Marks Municipality.

“I hold that the failure of the Board to consider utilising the option of public meetings in the light of the repeated recommendations that it do so, including in the report following the formal investigation, is unlawful,” the judgment states.

What happens next?

The High Court directed the MDB to restart the process at Section 26 of the Local Government: Municipal Demarcation Act. This requires the board to notify the public of its intention to reconsider municipal boundaries and invite written representations and views.

The public must be given at least 21 days to submit written representations. The MDB may also hold public meetings to obtain further input before reaching a decision.

Once the process has been completed, the board must publish its decision in the Provincial Gazette. The legislation also provides for a 30-day period during which objections may be lodged.

JB Marks Local Municipality was established on August 3, 2016, through the merger of the former Tlokwe City Council and Ventersdorp Local Municipality.

DA urges residents to make their voices heard

According to Hans-Jurie Moolman, who has been involved in the legal battle on behalf of the DA, the MDB must comply with all the requirements set out in the legislation, which it had previously failed to do.

He said public participation would be particularly important when the process resumed.

“A particularly important aspect of this process is public participation. I believe this is the basis residents will need to use to ensure that their voices are heard. It is very similar to what was done with the petition, but this time there will probably be public meetings. I think the aim will be to ensure that hundreds, if not thousands, of residents come together to make their views and feelings about the demerger known,” he added.

Why the court set aside the board’s decision

The DA approached the court on August 28 this year to have the MDB’s decision reviewed and set aside. The party argued that the board had failed to properly consider public participation before deciding against the proposed demerger.

At the centre of the judgment was Section 27 of the Local Government: Municipal Demarcation Act, which gives the MDB the option of holding public meetings, conducting a formal investigation or doing both after receiving written public submissions.

The MDB had decided in July last year to retain JB Marks, citing concerns about financial viability, governance, administrative costs, resource sharing and the potential destabilising effect of changing municipal boundaries.

However, the court found that the board had failed to properly consider whether public meetings should be held, despite repeated recommendations during the process.

Acting Judge Vivian found that the MDB had not provided reasons for failing to consider this option. The failure amounted to non-compliance with a mandatory and material procedure under the Demarcation Act.

In addition to ordering the MDB to restart the process at Section 26, the court declared its failure to consider public meetings unlawful and ordered the board to pay the DA’s legal costs.

At the time of publication, it had not been established whether the JB Marks Municipality intended to appeal the court’s decision.

Breaking news at your fingertips… Follow Caxton Network News on Facebook and join our WhatsApp channel.

Nuus wat saakmaak. Volg Caxton Netwerk-nuus op Facebook en sluit aan by ons WhatsApp-kanaal.

Read original story on www.citizen.co.za

At Caxton, every story is written by humans. We use AI only to perform quality checks - never to generate the news. Happy reading!

Support local journalism

Add The Citizen as a preferred source to see more from Network News in Google News and Top Stories.

wouterpienaar01

I am the editor of the Potchefstroom Herald since January 2026. I have a keen interest for sport and local community news. I have more than a decade of experience covering various beats. Journalism is a lifestyle.
Back to top button