Jacques van der Westhuyzen

By Jacques van der Westhuyzen

Head of Sport

Springbok player ratings in 13-8 loss to Ireland

There were few big standout performers in a tight game in Paris.

Ireland beat the Springboks 13-8 in a Pool B Rugby World Cup match in Paris on Saturday.

Here’s how The Citizen rated the performance of the Bok players, out of 10.


Damian Willemse 8: The fullback was the Boks’ best player by far. He was a threat with ball in hand, was strong in the air and played his part defensively and through his kicking.

Kurt-Lee Arendse 6: The winger had few chances on attack, chased high balls and tackled well but with so little space to work in was mostly anonymous.

Jesse Kriel 6: He made a few half-breaks and tried hard, but a few decisions let him down. He tackled well enough; decent without being commanding.

Damian de Allende 7: A strong, powerful performance again, he got over the gainline on a number of occasions and tackled strongly, but it is time for Andre Esterhuizen to get a go.

Cheslin Kolbe 6: The winger was strong in the air, he tried to get involved at every opportunity, but didn’t get much chance to show his skill set. He scored a good try out wide.

Manie Libbok 6: He created some opportunities for his outside men, and kicked well out of hand, but goal-kicking was poor and missed a few key tackles.

Faf de Klerk 7: Did what was asked of him. Varied his kicks out of hand and his service was generally good, keeping up a good tempo. He missed two kicks at goal.


Jasper Wiese 6: He tried to be a presence and made one or two big carries and tackles, but fell off the pace at times; just not the big presence the Boks needed.

Pieter-Steph du Toit 6: Another good showing in all departments, tackled and carried strongly at times, but more steady than properly influential.

Siya Kolisi 6: The Bok captain got stuck in, carried hard and often, and made a number of tackles, but not as commanding as usual.

Franco Mostert 7: He worked as hard as ever, moved from one ruck and tackle to the next and was a menace in the lineouts; very good outing once again.

Eben Etzebeth 7: The experienced lock worked hard, made a nuisance of himself in the lineouts and carried strongly, but left the action shortly after half-time.

Frans Malherbe 7: Scrummed very well at times, helping to get dominance in the set-pieces, and he made a number of tackles in a busy performance.

Bongi Mbonambi 6: He hit his jumpers in the lineouts, contributed to a good scrumming performance, but did not really get stuck.

Steven Kitshoff 7: Scrummed excellently at times, helping to win a few penalties, but also gave away. Made a number of tackles at close quarters.

Bench 7: RG Snyman was excellent in the second half, breaking tackles and carrying hard, while Ox Nche and Trevor Nyakane scrummed well, keeping the pressure on Ireland.

Kwagga Smith was also a menace at the breakdowns, while Jean Kleyn and Marco van Staden also played well. Deon Fourie missed one crucial throw in, while Cobus Reinach only got on late.

Read more on these topics

Ireland Rugby Team Rugby World Cup Springboks

Access premium news and stories

Access to the top content, vouchers and other member only benefits